Tamil Nadu Janmam Land Delay: Encroachments Threaten Gudalur Elephant Corridor | Chennai News

Section 17 lands in O’Valley in Gudalur region in the Nilgiris in Tamil Nadu

Tamil Nadu govt’s delay in implementing Section 17 of the Gudalur Janmam Estates (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1969, which has lasted about six decades, has led to widespread encroachments, including along elephant corridors in O’Valley within the Gudalur taluk of the Nilgiris.Gudalur serves as a critical elephant corridor linking Wayanad and the Mudumalai Tiger Reserve. However, this corridor is facing fragmentation due to encroachments and developments as well as rising conflicts between humans and elephants.A crucial issue concerns the classification of certain pieces of janmam land, formerly owned by janmis (landlords), as either ‘forest land’ to be designated for govt ownership or ‘ryotwari land’ that can be privately owned through a patta.Of the 80,000 acres of janmam land in the Gudalur region, about 50,300 acres had been leased out by the janmis. By the time the Act came into force in 1969, nearly 15,000 acres of rainforest had been converted into plantations.Plantation companies and individuals have staked claims as leaseholders or tenants, complicating the settlement process. “Political parties make promises during elections regarding these issues, but they remain unresolved after votes are polled,” says R Sathyaseelan, an activist from O’Valley.While the Act empowers the govt to manage leased plantation lands and provides a legal framework for legitimate occupants to acquire land rights, ongoing legal disputes over land classification have also resulted in restrictions on the provision of basic amenities and infrastructure in areas designated as ‘Section 17 lands’ and have enabled further encroachments.According to the district office of survey and settlement (DOSS), about 35,000 acres of Janmam land (largely in O’Valley) still fall under Section 17. “These lands are used by 11 major and 82 smaller estates for tea cultivation. About 300 cases related to these lands, including those involving encroachments, are pending before Madras high court and about three before Supreme Court,” says a DOSS official, requesting anonymity.Environmentalists say janmam lands extend over 80,000 acres in the Nilgiris, including ecologically sensitive shola forests that form a vital part of the Western Ghats. “It is described as the “overhead water tank” for half the country. Due to deforestation and encroachments, forest cover in the Nilgiris has shrunk to 20% of its original area,” says V Sivadas, managing trustee of Nilgiris-based environmental organisation Nest.Forest officials say human-elephant conflict is a growing problem that can only be contained by formally notifying and protecting the corridors. “As encroachments continue, the likelihood of conflict is likely to increase. Elephants tend to return to their traditional routes despite barriers.“The janmam land conflict is one of India’s longest-running policy failures,” says Siddhartha Krishnan, environmental sociologist and historian whose PhD thesis was on the issue. “The DMK govt of the day displayed intent in abolishing the janmam tenure. It should have simply assumed control of janmi leases to plantations. But in section 17 of the Act, the rider that the “govt may, if in their opinion, it is in the public interest to do so, by notice given to the person concerned, terminate the rights” created by the janmi, in retrospect, suggests policy uncertainty. This legal ambiguity has perpetuated a policy paralysis.”In Jan 2025, chief minister M K Stalin held a meeting to review Section 17, and the need to take over 34,986 acres in Gudalur where leases have expired.Lawyers say the Act was passed in 1969 and came into effect in 1974, and pattas under other sections 8, 9, and 10 were granted by 1978. Section 17 remains in limbo. The law requires the govt to terminate leases, take possession of the land and compensate lessees if necessary. However, this has not been done despite leases having expired.Many lessees occupy the land without paying rent or taxes, while seeking pattas by claiming tenant status. The law does not permit corporate entities to receive ryotwari pattas, which are meant for individuals cultivating annual crops. Despite court rulings upholding the Act, encroachers have continued to file appeals.“Large-scale encroachments continue unchecked, with some individuals building houses on several acres of land without approval. Estate owners have encouraged small-scale encroachments to protect their interests,” says S Anandaraja, secretary of the South India Repatriates Development Association. “Some encroachers have built buildings on 10 acres of encroached land. How is it possible without the complicity of local officials? All of the encroachers’ houses have electricity connections and water supply.” Despite several attempts, the district settlement officer could not be reached for a comment.Of man, land and lease